A lot of people might try to tell you that broiler pans aren’t necessary if you really want to broil something. But have you ever opened your broiler mid-cook to try to rotate a big hunk of meat? It’s hot, heavy and can be very inconvenient.
Broiler pans eliminate the need for rotating midway through because most of them have slats that allow air to circulate through them. So if you are in the market for one, check out the following list of the best non stick broiler pans.
Range Kleen Broiler Pans for Ovens
Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars
Kicking off our list is a high-quality broiling pan known for longevity. This Range Kleen brand boiler pan with rack is coated with porcelain. Porcelain is ideal for broiler pans because it can withstand very high heat.
In fact, this particular pan can be used to cook in temperatures as high as 1,025 degrees Fahrenheit! It’s core is made of steel which, adds to the longevity and durability. This is a mid-size broiler pan that measures 16 inches long by 12.5 inches wide.
Whirlpool 4396923 Porcelain Broiler Pan and Grid
Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars
If you own a Whirlpool oven, why not buy a Whirlpool brand broiler pan? This is a factory certified Whirlpool accessory that was designed specifically to be used in their appliances. It will fit a broad range of Whirlpool ovens and broilers.
The pan also comes with a roasting rack so you can catch all the juicer that come off your meats and veggies. Of course, this is a slotted broiler pan and it also comes with a durable porcelain coating to help food slide right off the surface.
GE WB48X10056 Genuine OEM Broiler Pan
Editors’ Choice: 4.7 out of 5.0 stars
This is another factory certified appliance accessory; this time from GE. This is an original equipment manufacturer nonstick broiler pan that will fit a host of GE ovens and broilers. It comes with it’s own roasting pan to help keep your broiler clean and catch flavorful juices.
The pan and the broiler grill measure 12.6” x 16.75” so it’s a pretty standard size. The pan itself is a little over an inch thick so it’s got some reassuring heft to it. This is a great product if you need to replace your old GE broiler pan.
Chicago Metallic Professional Roast Pan
Editors’ Choice: 4.7 out of 5.0 stars
Now this product is a bit different from our other entries so far. It’s still a non stick broiling pan, but for different reasons. Instead of a flat surface with slats cut into it, this pan is more of a wire rack. There is little surface for food to stick too, but the rack still cradles food securely for the broiler.
This non stick broiler pan set also comes with a roasting pan. The wire rack fits perfectly into the roasting pan so all you have to do is load your food and stick it in the broiler. The rack is even raised on the bottom and has convenient handles on both ends.
Norpro Broil/Roast Pan Set
Editors’ Choice: 4.7 out of 5.0 stars
Norpro’s take on broiling pans is unique, stylish and inventive. Instead of slats, this polished stainless steel broiling pan uses small perforations made into indents in the metal. This allows fat and grease to drain off while keeping your food elevated and well ventilated.
The roasting pan catches all the runoff and features a matching polished stainless steel design. The broiler pan and the roasting pan measure 12 by 9 inches and are both rectangular. And at just over 1 pound, this non stick broiler pan set is very lightweight.
Chicago Metallic 26639 Petite Roast Pan with Rack
Editors’ Choice: 4.7 out of 5.0 stars
If you are looking for a small non stick broiler pan this is a great one. Once again, it’s a Chicago Metallic brand pan that features a wire basket that sits inside a roasting pan. The wire basket is coated with a nonstick material as is the roasting pan.
This set is made from carbon steel which, is durable, lightweight and can even be used for baking. You can use it in the broiler, on your cook top or in your toaster oven. It’s very compact too at just 10 inches long and 7 inches wide.
Granite Ware Bake, Broil, and Grill Pan
Editors’ Choice: 4.6 out of 5.0 stars
This broiler pan set is unique in that it comes with 3 pieces. You get a roasting pan, a perforated broiler pan and a wire rack. The rack sits on top of the perforated broiler pan for exceptional air movement and easier cleanup.
The broiling pan is perforated as opposed to slotted and both pieces fit snugly inside the roasting pan. The set is made of carbon steel and the broiling rack features a nonstick, high temperature-resistant porcelain coating.
Non Stick Broiler Pan Buying Guide
Non stick broiler pans are not all created equal. You have to practice some discernment when shopping for one. To get the best non stick broiler pan, look for:
The Right Size
First and foremost, you will have to carefully measure the opening and the overhead clearance of your broiler and make sure that any pan you are considering can fit inside.
Coating
In most cases, porcelain enamel coatings are the best for broiler pans because these are very heat-resistant materials.
Air Flow
For crispier results in the broiler, make sure that any pan you use has plenty of slots or perforations for maximum air flow.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can you broil a non stick pan?
A: Don’t use pans in the broiler. Only use nonstick pans made specifically for broiler use.
Q: What pans are safe for broiling?
A: Broiling pans are ideal for cooing in a broiler. You can also use metal sheet pans with rims.
Q: Can you put aluminum foil in the broiler?
A: You can line a roasting pan with foil in place of a broiling pan but you should cut slits or perforations in the foil for air flow.
Final Thoughts
Broiling foods unlocks a unique flavor and texture: but only when you have the right cookware on hand. That’s why it’s important to have the best non stick broiler pan handy for when your next recipe calls for broiler assistance.
You will find a good variety of product-types on our list of the 7 best broiler pans to fit any cooking style. Be sure to start your shopping with the items on the list above!
