The 6 Best Pans for Baking Brownies [Buyers Guide]

The 6 Best Pans for Baking Brownies [Buyers Guide]

Baking brownies can be a fun project for you and your kids. And who doesn’t love fresh baked brownies warm out of the oven. But what isn’t so fun is the cleanup. Inferior pans are a nightmare to clean because everything sticks to them.

Even worse, low quality pans don’t conduct heat evenly which can leave you with par-baked and overcooked brownies in the same batch. But if you want a quality pan, here are 7 of the best pans for baking brownies. 

Best

Chicago Metallic Professional Slice Solutions Brownie Pan

Chicago Metallic Professional Slice Solutions Brownie Pan

 Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars 

First up is a handy offering from Chicago Metallic. This 9” x 13” baking pan features a removable divider. The divider makes it easy to bake 18 individual brownies about 3” x 2” in size. The pan is made of aluminized steel so it it sure to last a long time.

There is even a nonstick coating that makes this pan a breeze to clean. And of course, you can use this pan to bake at temperatures of up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit.

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe
  • Creates perfect brownies
  • Renowned manufacturer
Cons
  • Still requires light hand washing before dishwasher use
2

Ailelan Non Stick Brownie Pans With Dividers

Ailelan Non Stick Brownie Pans With Dividers

 Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars 

This pan also features a removable divider. The pan itself is 12 inches long and a little over 7 inches wide so you get a decent amount of baking capacity. The divider also has handles and it can be used to cut a single-piece batch of brownies. 

This pan is made of food grade carbon steel. Its BPA free and incredibly durable. So you don’t have to worry about scratching it or baked ingredients getting stuck to it. It also conducts heat very evenly even if you use the divider. 

Pros
  • Easy cutting
  • Makes 18 brownies
  • Stain resistant
Cons
  • A bit heavy
3

Sujude Non Stick Brownie Pans with Dividers

Sujude Non Stick Brownie Pans with Dividers

 Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars 

If nonstick is a priority for you then this pan may be of particular interest to you. It features a triple layered nonstick coating. What’s more, the triple nonstick coating also makes this pan corrosion-resistant. 

It is made of high carbon steel so it is durable and surprisingly lightweight. The pan itself is 8 inches by 12 inches and it comes with an 18-way divider. And like our last model, the divider has handles so it can be used for easy cutting. 

Pros
  • Lightweight
  • Great for lasagna too
  • Even heating
Cons
  • Only comes in one color
4

USA Pan Brownie Bowl Dessert Pan

USA Pan Brownie Bowl Dessert Pan

 Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars 

If you like making brownie bowls, this is the pan for you. This USA Pan has 6 brownie wells with raised centers. So this is a great pan when you want a subtle indent on the bottom of your brownies or other baked goods. 

The baking wells are rounded so they are different from the items on our list so far that were congenial to making square brownies. This is a great pan if you like making sundaes or pairing your brownies with ice cream as it creates a concave bowl shape. 

The pan is 15 inches long, 11.1 inches wide and the wells are about 1.75 inches deep. It’s coated with a high-quality silicone nonstick liner and is BPA and PTFE free. 

Pros
  • Limited lifetime warranty
  • Perfect for brownie bowls
  • Made of aluminized steel
Cons
  • A bit pricey
5

Boyan Brownie Pan with Dividers

Boyan Brownie Pan with Dividers

 Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars 

This pan is made of high carbon steel which is good for two reasons. The first being that it is very durable. No matter how much abuse you can dish out, this pan will stick with you for years and years. 

The second reason why high carbon steel is preferable for baking brownies is that it is a material that conducts heat very evenly. You aren’t likely ot get uneven baking when you use this pan. Aside from the high carbon steel design, it has an 18-way divider with handles. 

So yes, you can use the dividers to cut brownies. The pan is 8 inches wide and 12 inches long and features a triple nonstick coating. It even comes with a removable bottom liner. And the cool thing about this pan is that it comes in 2 attractive colors: rose gold and bronze. 

Pros
  • Great for all baked goods
  • Affordable
  • 2 inches deep
Cons
  • Not dishwasher safe
6

Sujude High Carbon Steel Baking Pan

Sujude High Carbon Steel Baking Pan

 Editors’ Choice: 4.8 out of 5.0 stars 

Our last entry is another Sujude product. This pan is also made of high carbon steel and if you’ve read this far then you already know the benefits of this material. This pan comes in an attractive “gold-o” color which looks a bit like a reddish gold. 

The nonstick finish is stain, corrosion and rust resistant so this pan will maintain it’s good looks for a long time. And while you can’t clean this pan in the dishwasher, it’s very easy to clean by hand. It’s also great for making rice crispy treats, casseroles, enchiladas and lasagna. 

Pros
  • Cool color
  • High carbon steel design
  • Compact
Cons
  • Divider handles get hot

Pan for Baking Brownies Buyer’s Guide

Brownies can be very finicky. So if you want to get the best pan for baking brownies, we suggest looking for the following:

Nonstick Coating

A nonstick coating helps with cleanup, obviously. But a good nonstick coating will also make it easier to get your brownies out of the pan in one piece once they are done. 

Treated Steel

Treated steel is the preferred choice for bakers. You are going to want to get a pan that is either high carbon or aluminized. 

Removable Dividers

This isn’t a must but it can be very helpful. When you have to cut your brownies to divide them, you can risk scratching the nonstick coating with a knife. Pans with removable dividers are safer to use. 


Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What size pan do you bake brownies in?

A: It really depends on how many brownies you want to make but the typical pan size fro brownies is 12 x 8 inch or 13 x 9 inch.

Q: How long do you cook brownies in the perfect pan?

A: With the ideal pan, you are looking at a bake time of about 25 minutes.

Q: Do you spray the pan when baking brownies?

A: You can. In most cases, spraying the pan will prevent burning – especially if you’re using a glass pan. Shortening, cooking spray or butter can be used to grease the pan.


Some Final Advice

Remember that you don’t have to pay a fortune to get the best pan for baking brownies. The pans on our list are affordable and they are all ideal for baking brownies. And most of them are versatile enough to use for other types of foods and baked goods. 

With these pans, your only limitation is your imagination. So whether you need to prepare for a big church bake sale or just want to have some home baked sweets in the pantry, check the pans on our list out!

OrbReviews Editorial Team

The OrbReviews Editorial Team (OET) is made out of experts in the product research and engaging content creation space. In addition, OET is passionate about researching kitchen related products and sharing the learning with our readers.